Fort Apache Limestone Site near OW Ranch In to the Acetic Acid Bath from the Permian Fort Apache Limestone East of Payson
 

Updated  8/21/22
 

 Our exploration of the OW Ranch Site will conclude with some new images and finds! The site did not pan out for a good locality for silicified microfossils because the preservation was very poor because the fossils were only partially silicified. Many fragments of fossils came out of the Muriatic bath (HCl).

Recently, on a trip to the Home Depot store, we found they sold some very strong acetic acid, 30% compared with the supermarket strength of about 4 percent. We though we would try it on some residual pieces of the limestone we had from breaking rocks apart with a hand sledge. Acetic acid, as you know is much safer than Muriatic. It also does not burn up organic material like bones, and conodonts jaws. It was hoped we might find a few of these in the acid residues! It is very slow going, since it is much weaker but after a few weeks we knew it was worth the effort. Several button like fish teeth were recovered, and some really surprising other material as well. But no conodonts.

Click to enlarge to full size:

Trilobites:

 Phillipsia sp. This is the left side of the cranidium, or free cheek. The genial spine is at bottom, and the big round cut out on the right edge - is the cut out for the trilobites eye. At top is the dorsal rim that outlines the front of the animal. Unfortunately, a lot of silica was still attached to the left side and obscures it a bit. Still, we were not expecting to find this in a few broken chips left over from our rock cracking.

Plant Cuticle:

 Several items seen in this image. On the top is an urchin spine, tipped with a little circlet of quartz crystals. But the major find here is the land plant cuticle! This is of course the waxy protein coat on the plants leaf cells to seal them from water loss. Cuticle is tough and resilient and can be found in both marine and terrestrial deposits, and usually has impressions of leaf veins and such impressed on their inner face.

This material is not a contaminant from the outside. It came out of a fresh batch of well rinsed limestone and from near the very core of the rock, not the outside. There is no doubt it was in the Fort Apache Sea and buried along with the marine fossils.

 Plant Cuticle. A series of close ups of the cuticle under a transmission optical microscope.
 Plant Cuticle. Scale at bottom of all these images.
 Plant Cuticle. Leaf veins preserved in the cuticle!
 Plant Cuticle. Piece with leaf veins.

Foram:

 indet sp. A small piece of blue material that was the size of a grain of sand was spotted under the stereo microscope when examining the acid fines. This has never been seen before in the stronger muriatic acid fines. Close examination with the powerful trinocular microscope and top lit with a powerful halogen fiber optic lamp, we can see intricate details. The blue is most likely some copper mineral, and the red spots maybe cuprite. But on closer examination - a surprise was waiting....
 Foram. For this much higher power view, we can now see a round disk shaped foram was embedded in the mineral. Look even more closely and you can see small indentations all over its surface. None of this would have been recovered in the muriatic acid.

Fish Teeth:

 Fish Teeth and Gastropod. As you can see by the tiny gastropod with has very poor preservation, this material is not so great for fossil recovery of mollusks. But for the VERY FIRST TIME we found this gorgeous tiny fish tooth in the acid fines. It is actually two stuck together here, they are cap shaped and are the type that would have been used to crush the numerous gastropods and clams found in this formation. The actual fish would have been quite small, about 2-3 inches long like a minnow.
 Fish Teeth. A total of two separate sets of teeth found. You can clearly see the capped dome shape on the right one.

Quartz Crystals:

 On the tip of one urchin spine, a ring of interesting milky quartz crystals was seen. The spine itself is very badly preserved and is really rough looking!

Paleo HOME