Fort Apache Limestone Site near OW Ranch survey results from the Permian Fort Apache Limestone East of Payson
 

Updated  7/2/22
 

Introduction

Outcrops of fossiliferous Permian Fort Apache Limestone are very rare off the Reservation, most localities where the rock outcrops such as in Sedona or Pine have no fossils to speak of. Because we wish to promote the collection, curation and study of the Fort Apache Limestone microfossils, we are going to give you a map to the locality below. If your looking for big flashy fossils laying around the ground, this is definitely NOT your location! To collect here, we parked next to the site along the road way and picked up promising pieces of limestone that had fossils externally visible. But there is no guarantee that when you dissolve this rock in muriatic acid, that you will have abundant silicified fossils. Many of the fossils are also calcified and will dissolve in the acid.

While the fossils recovered at this site were not as well preserved as on the High line Trail site, a good assortment of micro and small fossils were recovered from the acid fines. We will highlight here some of the best of what we found - Over a dozen fossil types and many more gastropod species.

The Locality

(Click to Enlarge)
 Fr33 is a decent dirt road, but with a bit of washboard. Probably dont want to take the family car down this one, you might rattle it to death. Any pickup or off road vehicle will make it fine. Marked in red is the location of the outcrop, on the north side of a straight area in the forest where the outcrop appears as a light grey limestone coming down the hillside. You can climb this as well and get better specimens as you head a bit up the hill.

Some Photos of the Site:

(Click to Enlarge)

 
 
 

What was found

About 150 pounds in rock were put through the acid bath, and the following were found under the microscope:

1. A large amount of Urchin material 
2.  A Dozen of poorly persevered Branching / Encrusting Bryozoans
3.  Half a dozen Serpulid Worm domiciles (Chonetes)
4.  About a dozen of nice Scaphopods, some approaching pencil sized.
5.  A single Ostracod!
6.  A hundred or so of both superbly - and poorly preserved Gastropods
7.  Sponges, about a table spoon worth
8.  half a dozen Trilobite bits and one very nice pygidium
9.  Lots of small bivalves - very generic low diversity
10.  A few Straparollus gastropod parts with two complete larger specimens
11.  And one Brachiopod (other than productids)
12.  half a dozen productids
13.  Bellerophontid Gastropods
14.  Quartz crystals


And here is what was NOT found that had been at other sites along the trail:

1.  No productid spines
2.  No solitary rugose corals
3.  Not a single crinoid ossicle
4.   No metal particles
5.  No Nautiloids
6.  NO winged clams
7. NO sponge roots

For a site with moderately poor preservation of fossils, there were a few surprises!

The Fossil Photos.

Identifications are based on the very limited literature on the Fort Apache limestone, and the more common Kaibab formation, both are Permian, however the Kaibab is later in time. GSA Memoir 89 by Steven Winters in 1963 is the definitive source.

A few words on how these photos were taken. Using an Amscope stereo microscope, one or two dozen shots of each subject were taken with the focus shifted a bit between shots. The focus stacking software Picolay was used to combine the images to obtain one frame of fully sharp focus. Thousands of frames are treated in this manner and the final images of the Fort Apache micro fossils you see here are the results of a huge amount of work! Enjoy.

Trilobites:

 Phillipsia sp. Surprisingly, a few front rims, a solitary genial spine, and a bit of thoraxic ribs was found, and one mostly complete fully silicified pygidium.

 Phillipsia sp. A lot of material was glued to it with silica, but you can clearly see the full thickness of this cast.
 Phillipsia sp. One genial spine on the left, along side a "rack" of trilobite ribs. Hard to believe such a delicate thing as this survived the lag deposit.

Brachiopods:

Genus and species indet. ONE brach was found, this is its underside on its pedicle valve.

 Genus and species indet. Top side of the same brach.

Bryozoans:

 This appears to be an urchin spine coated with an encrusting Bryozoan.

 There were two types of bryozoans found, the Fenestrate type and the Y branching tubular type.
 The branching type imaged closer to show pores. Again, preservation here is not the best, but you can see the openings for the zooids.
 The Y branches commonly found, same species.
The Fenestellid bryozoans made their appearance with these few fragments.
40x Close up of the branching tubular type.
 40x Close up of the Fenestellid type. Each white bump contained a single zooid.

Chonetids (Serpulid Worms):

 Essentially, these are serpulid worms domiciles. (like Spirorbis). Winters never found or photographed these! These tubes are flat on one side, because they were formed on sea weeds and when the weeds died, the tube falls off and has a flat on it.

 The serpulid worms, with one still attached to a bit of shell.

Bivalves:

Astartella subquadrata. This is the dominant species in the Fort Apache Limestone everywhere we have looked.

 Aviculopecten sp. A small fragment of what was a much larger shell. This is the hinge area of the right valve. Winters found exactly the same piece!
 Edmondia sp. The common shells were also found still together, they died in the sediment without separating.
 Astartella subquadrata. One of the best specimens.

Quartz Crystals:

 Silicon dioxide sp. Some nice optically clear types and some milky types as well.

Close up of one of the crystals, that was very well formed. But is only 1mm in size.

Gastropods:

 Knightite modestus, A beautiful spiral wound genus, somewhat resembling Bellerophontids.

 Naticopsis apachensis, Anothere stunning shape for a small shell, reminds me of shells of today we found on the beaches of Florida.
 Apachella franciscana. The thick walled nature of these gastropods made for excellent preservation! You can look right up inside these like the day they came to rest on the sea floor.
 Genus and species indet. The smallest species in the Fort Apache.
 Genus and species indet. Same species as above, but next to a head of a pin.
Genus and species indet. Beehive shaped, very distinctive.
 Paleostylus sp. Another thick walled and very well preserved genus.
 Apachella translirata. The thinner wall of the shell meant few of this genus was found intact.
 Meekospria knighti. A very "snail like" look, we found about three of these very distinctive specimens.
 Genus and sp. indet. Thin walled and break apart very easily. These remind me of the cinnomon buns at Safeway...
 Genus and sp. indet. One solitary turriculate gastropod was found, and is next to a pin head here.
 Bellerophon sp. On the left side is the top of the Bellerophon. The right is another shell attached to it.
 Smaller Bellerophon sp. specimens.

Ostracods:

 Genus and species indet. Only ONE Ostracod was found, they were extremely rare at this site. Yes that is the head of a pin next to it!

Scaphapods:

Plagioglypta canna. A nice assortment of scaphopods, the younger teleoconchs are at the top.

Plagioglypta canna Sizes ranged from only a few mm to over an inch. Both smooth and ribbed types found. These are Teleoconchs, which are juviniles.

Sponges:

The Hexactanellid sponges we found here were quite foamy looking, and were no doubt much of the source for the silica in the fossils here.

  Close up of the foamy nature.

 

Straparollus Gastropods:

 Straparollus kaibabensis Two larger specimens here, once they get to about an inch in size, they start to develop the bumps along the shell as seen here.
Straparollus kaibabensis One piece of limestone we found had a cross section of a Straparollus.

Straparollus kaibabensis Juvinile Straparollus. No bumps on shell, but some have early ridges.

Straparollus kaibabensis Same as above, this one has a ridge around its edges. This goes away when they grow larger and become bumps.

Straparollus kaibabensis Killer tiny specimen of the juvinile complete with the protoconch! (the very starting bud in the middle)

Urchin:

Echinocrinus trudifer Hordes of Urchin spines, plates, and dorsal plates were found.

Echinocrinus trudifer. It appears there are two dominant types of urchins here, one with smooth spines, and one with spikes.

Echinocrinus trudifer Very common is the individual spine plates.
Echinocrinus trudifer Spine detail.

Some of the smooth spines.
Echinocrinus trudifer This appears to be one of the plates on the top of an urchin, the inlets for the water vascular system.
Echinocrinus trudifer Close up of a spine plate.

Paleo HOME