Fort Apache Limestone Site 4 survey results from the Permian Fort Apache Limestone East of Payson
 

Updated  10/4/19
 

 Our Survey this week included all of site 4, which zone 1 had limestone and zone 2 (the second half) was only red Shnebly Hill Sandstone and was without fossils. Fossils in Site 4 were few and far between, most rock had no visible silicified fossils at all. Preservation was moderate to poor, and the fossil types found were few in number.

Lets review so far all the sites covered, with this map. As I mentioned before, I am posting this map to encourage other microfossil collectors to visit this area. It is strictly for microfossils - Very few normal size fossils can be found.

 Here we see all four sites plus Three more that are in the process of exploration. The parking area for the trail is at lower left. Two outcrops occur. The Outcrop 1 is the main outcrop surveyed so far, and we are looking at the scree slope material as it flows over the trail. It is not possible to actually go to the outcrops, since they are on extremely steep cliffs. Outcrop 2 does indeed have more fossils and will be the study area soon.

Click to enlarge to full size

What was found

As far as what was found in a one gallon zip lock bag of rock, this list highlights the best preserved specimens:

1.  A very small amount of Urchin material that was very poorly preserved
2.  Half a dozen of poorly persevered Branching / Encrusting Bryozoans
3.  THREE Serpulid Worm domiciles (Chonetes)
4.  A Dozen nice Scaphopods - all small
5.  Two species of Ostracods
6.  Several dozen of both average - and poorly preserved Gastropods
7.  Several water clear quartz crystals
8.  Half  a dozen tiny Trilobite bits 
9.  Dozens of small Bivalves - very generic
10.  A few Straparollus gastropod parts
11.  Four partial Brachiopods (other than productids)
12.  One productid spine
13,  One probable Orthocone Nautiloid

And here is what was NOT found that had been at other sites along the trail:
1.  No Sponges or sponge roots
2.  No solitary rugose corals
3.  Not a single crinoid ossicle
4.  No Bellerophontid Gastropods
5.  No Metal coated sand grains
6.  No larger fossils like productids or urchin spines

For a site so poor in fossils, there were a few interesting surprises!

The Fossil Photos.

A few words on how these photos were taken. Using an Amscope stereo microscope, one or two dozen shots of each subject were taken with the focus shifted a bit between shots. The focus stacking software Picolay was used to combine the images to obtain one frame of fully sharp focus. Thousands of frames are treated in this manner and the final images of the Fort Apache micro fossils you see here are the results of a huge amount of work! Enjoy.

Trilobites:

 Phillipsia sp. 15x For such a poor site, we did find more trilobite Doublure (rims) than the previous site. Thier color and composition is only shared by the flat clam shaped ostracods - which are of course also arthropods.

Brachipods:

 Pseudodielasma sp. 3.5x Four brachs were found, three seen here and one to be illustrated in the Chonetes section. Most surviving pieces are the umbo region near the hinge, which appears strongest.

Bryozoans:

3.5x The branching bryozonas made thier appearance, most being extremely flattened. Why?

Chonetids (Serpulid Worms):

 10x Three were found, a very small number indeed. Two are on the surfaces of the shell of other invertebrates, and one loose. On the left is the only loose one we found, which was more than likely attached to a sea weed. The center specimen is on the inside of a brach valve, and the third is on a mollusk.

Bivalves:

3.5x This site had a few nice mollusks, including these bivalves. No winged clams seen here however.

Quartz Crystals:

 15x A few nice sand grain sized quartz crystals. Here we see some individuals, a cluster and a flake of mica.
30x Closer view of the quartz crystals.
40x The single mica flake has significance. Mica normall forms in either igneous granites or metamorphic rock such as gneiss or schist. Many of the pieces we find are crystal shaped, and most likely from granite washed in from the distant shore.
40x Dark field microscope shot of one of the quartz crystals.
 40x Another dark field shot at 40x.
 100x shot showing a close up with the dark field microscope.

Gastropods:

 3.5x As found at most of the sites, gastropods are the dominant fossils. Variety was poor here, and most were badly broken.

Ostracods:

 Genus and species indet. 15x Only a small handful of ostracods were found, both the clam like and ear shaped.

Scaphapods:

 Plagioglypta canna 3.5x Sizes ranged from only a few mm to over an inch. Both smooth and ribbed types found

Productid Spines:

 Bellaclathrus spinosus 15x Only ONE spine was found, very peculiar. This one looks like a mastadon tusk...

Nautiloids:

 3.5x One orthocone nautiloid is seen here on the bottom. At upper right seems to be part of the calice for a rugose coral, but this is uncertain. The pieces on the upper left are most likely urchin parts.

Straparollus Gastropods:

 Straparollus kaibabensis 7x Only a few fragments found.

Urchin:

 Echinocrinus trudifer 7x Very few urchin pieces and get this - NO spines.

Paleo HOME