Fort Apache Limestone Site 3 Zone 2 survey results from the Permian Fort Apache Limestone East of Payson
 

Updated  9/8/19
 

 Our survey continues with what has been so far the least fossiliferous of all the sites sampled so far. The fines from the acid bath were dominated by ground up shell bits and very few fossils intact were found. This is quite different from the first half of site 3. We also saw the return of dozens of stunning clear quartz crystals, the first stromatoporoid ever found, several scaphopods transitioning from teleoconch to adult. Plenty of terriginous material (dirt) mixed in this batch, and the rocks appeared to be more carbonate than previous batches and foamed violently in the muriatic acid dillutions.

 Click this thumbnail for the larger size. The parking area for the trail is at bottom, and the sites are marked with pins. Site 3 is marked and is the start of this survey, and extends halfway to site 4 marker. This write up is based on the collection of one full ziploc bag of rocks from the area of site 3.5 - 4. Again, this site is one of the best for micro fossils in Arizona, but few if any larger fossils can be found here.

What was found

As far as what was found in a one gallon zip lock bag of rock, this list highlights the best preserved specimens:

1. A very small amount of Urchin material that was very poorly preserved
2.  Dozens of poorly persevered Branching / Encrusting Bryozoans
3.  Half a dozen Serpulid Worm domiciles (Chonetes)
4.  Dozens of nice Scaphopods, some approaching pencil sized.
5.  One species of Ostracods
6.  Several dozen of both superbly - and poorly preserved Gastropods
7.  One sand grain covered with the metal coating
8.  Two tiny Trilobite bits 
9.  Only four or five Bivalves - very generic
10.  A few Straparollus gastropod parts with one complete pea sized specimen
11.  And three partial Brachiopods (other than productids)
12.  Two productid spines
13,  Stromatoporoid pieces

And here is what was NOT found that had been at other sites along the trail:
1.  No Sponges or sponge roots
2.  No solitary rugose corals
3.  Not a single crinoid ossicle
4.  No Bellerophontid Gastropods
5.  No Nautiloids
6.  NO winged clams

For a site so poor in fossils, there were a few surprises!

The Fossil Photos.

A few words on how these photos were taken. Using an Amscope stereo microscope, one or two dozen shots of each subject were taken with the focus shifted a bit between shots. The focus stacking software Picolay was used to combine the images to obtain one frame of fully sharp focus. Thousands of frames are treated in this manner and the final images of the Fort Apache micro fossils you see here are the results of a huge amount of work! Enjoy.

Trilobites:

 Phillipsia sp. For this gallon of rock sample, only two tiny fragments of the highly sought after arthropod were found. A section of thoraxic ribs on the left, a pices of cephalon, and on the right a doublure (Rim). The color is diagnostic - ONLY trilobites and the ear shaped ostracods (also arthropods) have the carmel colored silica.

Brachipods:

 Pseudodielasma sp. Three partial brachs were found, which were the largest specimens in our sample mix.

Bryozoans:

 The habit of these bryozoans is both encrusting and solitary small branches. Most specimens the apertures were not clearly defined due to poor preservation. They would often encrust urchin spines to the point that the spine was unrecognisable.

Chonetids (Serpulid Worms):

 Loose specimens are the remains of being attached to sea weed, and thus are loose in the fines with one very flat side. Also shown here, several chonetids are cemented to bryozoans which obviously were dead at the time. At the top we have an urchin spine encrusted by bryozans and then the serpulid attached on to the bryozoan.

Bivalves:

This is all we found intact for bivalves! While the fines were mostly ground up shell hash, none were recognisable. 

Astartella subquandrata (top), Palaeonucula levatiformis (upper right), Sanguinolites sp. (? Lower left)

Quartz Crystals:

 Dozens of very nicely formed quartz crystals made their appearance in the mix. It seems the more we find these, the worse preservation the fossils.
 Close ups of some of the better terminated specimens. Realize that these are about the same size as a grain of sand.
 40x maximum magnification view of some of the fine crystal terminations.

Gastropods:

 About half a teaspoon of gastropods were found in the gallon of rock. Half were so badly preserved, but still half were decent. A large percentage were the spiral cones with the deep ribbing.
 Cibecuia cedarensis Two of these new gastropod types were found, we had not found them before at other sites.
 Apachella turbiniformis These are pretty uncommon too. The preservation on these is excellent.
 Knightites modestus Some of my favorites, these resemble Bellerophon, but are not related.
 Palaeonucula levatiformis Barrel shaped with positive curvature.
 Cibecuia cedarensis This was the largest specimen of this genus found.
 Genus and species indet. These high spired turriculate cones are some of the most exciting finds when preserved well like this. The smallest is less than the size of a pin head.
 Paleostylus sp. Some of these cones are superbly detailed. The transverse ribbing is diagnostic.
 Apachella arizonensis Well worn, but the shape is unmistakeable.
 Apachella arizonensis
 Genus and species indet. There are hordes of these super tiny gastropods everywhere. They may be juviniles of some of the larger finds.
 Goniasma terebra Stunning shape with clear circular ribbing.

Ostracods:

 Genus and species indet. Only one type of ostracod was found, the small clam shaped types.

Scaphapods:

 Plagioglypta canna Sizes ranged from only a few mm to over an inch. Both smooth and ribbed types found
 Plagioglypta canna The smaller scaphopods showed once again the change from the circular ribbing of the juvinile teleoconchs to the smooth surface of the adults. The juvinile part easily breaks off in life and allows the water to exit out the top when they are feeding in the mud.

Productid Spines:

 Bellaclathrus spinosus Only two spines from these productids were found. No larger brachs were in the mix, we can only infer ther identity with thier spines.

Stromatoporoid:

 Stroms are a type of encrusting sponge with radial columns internal to the outside to inside surfaces. This one is encrusting a spiny urchin spine (Echinocrinus trudifer)
 Close up of the edge showing the radial tubes charecteristic of stromatoporoids.
 Another close up of edge.
 Surface close up. This is the first time ever we have found such an animal in the Fort Apache.

Straparollus Gastropods:

 Straparollus kaibabensis Same species as in the overlying Permian Kaibab formation. Wide veiw showing the complete specimen surrounded by sections of the whorl.
 Straparollus kaibabensis Juvinile. One of the best specimens for showing the "Protoconch", which is the tiny bud shaped part in the very center. This is how the gastropod hatches from its egg, and then starts to spiral shortly thereafter.

Urchin:

 Echinocrinus trudifer Very few urchin parts survived the taphonomic filter at this site. Seen here are some spines, tubercle plates and a few water vascular system pores.
 Echinocrinus trudifer Close up of plates found.

Paleo HOME