Fort Apache Limestone Site 3 Zone 1 survey results from the Permian Fort Apache Limestone East of Payson
 

Updated  9/2/19
 

 Our in depth site survey continues with the first half of Site 3, along the Highway 260 trail - The Sinkhole trail. Starting with site one where the outcrop starts, each section is about 80 - 120 paces long. Each section is divided into two zones, zone 1 for the first half and zone 2 for the second half. This was done because of the huge variations in the preservation and fauna along each section. Here is a map of the locations examined so far and those to come. Exact GPS coordinates were taken of each location, which usually started and ended with an easily found landmark such as a wash or huge boulder or stump.

 Click this thumbnail for the larger size. The parking area for the trail is at bottom, and the sites are marked with pins. Site 3 is marked and is the start of this survey, and extends halfway to site 4 marker. Again, this site is one of the best for micro fossils in Arizona, but few if any larger fossils can be found here. It takes a lot of work to collect the promising rocks, haul them out and spend days or weeks in the acid bath. Then there is the hours sorting under the microscope, then photos and identification.

What was found at this site was far less quantities of fossils than any other site surveyed so far. Preservation for most fossils was poor and many of the specimens fell apart or were so crystallized that they were unusable. However - several exciting finds found here and no where else were obtained and one very special fossil in particular - a trilobite glabella, the most complete one we have ever found at this outcrop was pulled out of the acid fines. More on that later.

As far as what was found in a one gallon zip lock bag of rock, this list highlights the best preserved specimens:

1. A small amount of Urchin material
2.  Plenty of poorly persevered Branching Bryozoans
3.  Serpulid Worm domiciles (Chonetes)
4.  Dozens of nice Scaphopods
5.  Two species of Ostracods
6.  Hordes of both superbly and poorly preserved Gastropods
7.  Several excellent Bellerophontid Gastropods
8.  Trilobite bits including a mostly complete glabella and two pygidiums
9.  Many tiny Bivalves including a superb assortment of winged clams
10.  Half a dozen Straparollus gastropod juveniles and sub adults
11.  And finally, two partial Brachiopods (other than productids)

And here is what was NOT found that had been at other sites along the trail:
1.  No Sponges or sponge roots
2.  No solitary rugose corals
3.  Not a single crinoid ossicle
4.  No quartz crystals or metallic pieces
5.  No Nautiloids
6.  Finally, NO productid spines or parts.

For a site so poor in fossils, it made up for quantity and quality with a good variety. It may be that the upcoming zone 2 is the start of a really rich location. Well see.

The Fossil Photos.

A few words on how these photos were taken. Using an Amscope stereo microscope, one or two dozen shots of each subject were taken with the focus shifted a bit between shots. The focus stacking software Picolay was used to combine the images to obtain one frame of fully sharp focus. Thousands of frames are treated in this manner and the final images of the Fort Apache micro fossils you see here are the results of a huge amount of work! Enjoy.

Trilobites:

 Phillipsia sp. For only a gallon of rock, half a dozen or so pieces of the single species of trilobite we have found at this site were collected. The upper left is a free cheek with eye cutout, on the right is a partial pygidium. Below are trilobite doublures - the rim around the body. Other pieces shown below are even more interesting!
 Phillipsia sp. A superbly preserved pygidium! Still, not enough to identify the trilobite other than it is of the Genus Phillipsia. One more piece is missing...
 Phillipsia sp. And this is the final piece of the puzzle. After thousands of pounds of rock, this is only the second and by far the best glabella we have found. It is smooth with a crenulated rim, and about twice the size of the pygidium central extension for comparison.
 The completed cephalon, pygidium fitted onto a trilobite of very similar appearance, Phillipsia Perocidens. Identifying Permian trilobites is not easy. Most specimens are fragmentary with critical pieces missing. Whole ones are exceedingly rare. The quest continues! Until we find better more complete specimens, this one will get this identification: "Phillipsia sp. c.f. Phillipsia Perocidens". (c.f. is a paleontology nomenclature term meaning "closely following".)

Ostracods:

 More ostracods than in the previous section, dominated by the ear shaped translucent straw colored types. Also seen are the oval clam shell types which were quite rare here.
 Two nice specimens, on the left is a top view showing the shell ornamentation and general shape. On the right is one that is both halves still intact standing on edge showing the separate parts. They are quite thick for shier size!
 This second type of ostracod is more bean shaped and bears no ornamentation on the shell. You can see the line between halves on the right one.

Brachiopods:

 Pseudodielasma sp. Very rare indeed are normal brachiopods in the Fort Apache. This is only the second or third time we have ever found any at all. This is a top view of both specimens, the left one mostly complete.
 Pseudodielasma sp. Underside, showing that the left one has a pedicle opening and thus this is the Pedicle valve.

Chonetids (Serpulids)

 Only three serpulid tubes were found. The back is totally flat and are normally glued to plant surfaces.

Scaphopods:

 Plagioglypta canna. A nice selection of small scaphopods, both adults and juveniles. Both ribbed and smooth types seen here, and the small ones at the bottom are teleoconchs from juveniles.
 Plagioglypta canna. A very nice specimen showing the horizontally ribbed juvenile teleoconch on the left is gradiating to the smooth section to the right of the adult shell. When the adult phase is reached, the teleoconch breaks off and this then is the water outlet for feeding from the larger open end where the animal resides normally buried in the mud.

Bryozoans:

 Small bryozoans that are either branching or encrusting spines and shells were found. Most had terrible preservation and were nearly smooth or crystallized on the outside. Here are a few with the holes clearly seen. A head of a pin for scale is shown.

Echinoderms (Urchins)

 Echinocrinus sp. Few urchin parts were found. Here a few spines and an ambulacral plate is seen. No spine plates or water vascular plates were found.

Straparollus Gastropods:

 Straparollus Kaibabensis. The number of Straparollus parts is increasing as we go east along the outcrop. Here are some juveniles and mid size pieces. Several larger pieces showing the adult ornamentation on the coils were found as well.

Gastropods:

 Large numbers of gastropods were found, but half were so badly preserved from over silicification, or erosion. This rock is more carbonate than other sites and the silicified fossils within were far less detailed. This pile of shells here is the total sum of what I pulled out of the gallon of rock.

Now lets detail the different types. Identifications are from Winters monograph GSA 89.

 Cinnamon Buns - Apachella prodontia sp., Tall spired - Worthenia arizonensis sp.
 Apachella translirata sp. These were never seen before and Winters had identified them from several he had found in the Smithsonian survey.
 Genus and species indet. Only one of these beauties found. And it was quite a bit larger than most gastropods.
Genus and species indet. We found lots of these deeply incised cones, very distinctive.
 Apachella prodontia. More examples of this very common gastropod.
 Genus and species indet. This and the next gastropod are way too generic looking for even Winters to identify.
 Genus and species indet. Very generic.
 Genus and species indet. Not even listed in Winters descriptions, this one appears frequently in selected outcrops. It is a gorgeous tall spire and can be found in very small sizes as seen here. The nail head on the right is actually the point of a straight pin.
 Goniasma terebra sp. A few of these stunning ribbed specimens were found with intricate details.
 Goniasma terebra sp.
 Goniasma sp. The shape of these reminds me of a bee hive.
 Tiny tall spired gastropods, and the small juveniles of unknown species sitting on a penny.
 Tall spired gastropods next to the head of a pin.
 Knightites modestus. With part of the shell missing allowing us to see the coils inside. It is almost like a ball or sphere.

 

Bivalves (Clams)

 Most of the material from the acid fines were ground up bivalves. Few whole ones were found, but there were surprises! More than any other site so far, the winged clams made a good showing and some of the specimens were amazing.

 Parallelodon anaklastum. The gorgeous winged clams. This site so far has more of these than any other. It was always a surprise to find these gems mixed in with the hash, most were broken and the wings chipped. Here several perfect specimens were to be had. What a great find!
 Palaeonucula levatiformis. The most common clam found, many of them worn. Some are sub millimeter sized.
 Bakevellia sulcata. The OTHER winged clam. The deeply incised groove is diagnostic.
 Palaeonucula levatiformis. The most common clam found, bottom view.
 Astartella subquandrata. Less common but unique in shape. Less worn specimens here have nice surface grooves.

Bellerophontids

 Bellerophon sp. Top view showing dorsal ridge characteristic of the genus.
 Bellerophon sp. Same specimen on its side showing the almost cephalopod like appearance. Bellerophontids are somewhere in between gastropods and monoplacophorans. In other words - They are very primitive gastropods with their planispiral coiling.

Paleo HOME