Site 1 Survey from the Permian Fort Apache Limestone East of Payson

Updated  7/23/19
 

 We will be eventually surveying the entire High line Trail outcrop in small sections, bounded by visible landmarks in small short sections up to 500 feet long. This first section is Site 1, and is the first outcrop on the Sinkhole trail you come to going eastward, about a quarter mile in. The fossils of each section are very different and the preservation was seen to vary considerably. This series of surveys are intended to gather a specific amount of material (2 one gallon zip lock bags) from each section, and report the findings here from the acid bath fines. Site 1 is also variable in content across its span. The west end is dominated by bryozoans and ostracods. The east end is far more fossiliferous and has few bryozoans but loads of tiny gastropods, juvenile scaphopods, and sponges. Larger pieces of trilobites start to appear here.

Now the reason I am posting the location of this locality is to bring other micro fossil collectors to this very unique world class site. Dont bother coming here if your not ready to spend hours dissolving limestone in muriatic acid, and spending countless hours searching through the acid fines under a stereo microscope to find your quarry! This is not a site where you can just pick up fossils off the ground. It is for the dedicated micro fossil sleuth to make new exciting discoveries. If you are interested in this type of work, or just curious what fauna we found at this amazing site - Read on...

NOTE: Click all images to get the larger 1290 x 960 sized image.

 The authors set up includes a quality binocular microscope (Amscope), sorting trays and vials, a strong white LED light source and of course my helper cat Rory.

Bryozoans

 We find two types of bryozoans in the Fort Apache Limestone. This one, a small branching type with very tiny pores dominated the fauna at the west end (zone 1) of the Site 1 outcrop. They are very delicate and care must be used when picking up the small branches.
 The second type of bryozoan found here is the Fenestrate types. These originally fan shaped organisms were anchored to the sea bottom and hosted a colony of literally millions of zooids in their fans. Two types are shown here.
 Close up of the specimen on the bottom in the above image. Note the webbing is smooth between holes.
 The dominant type is this bryozoan. Small pockets in the protrusions between holes held the tiny animals, which spread out feeding arms to capture plankton for food.

Chonetids

 Tube worms are everywhere in the Fort Apache. They are found singly as seen here as they fell off the vegetation when the plant dies. Also they are found covering all sorts of other organisms including urchins, gastropods, corals and anything they can cement their tests to. Two of them on the right are a different species with ridges along their whorls.
 Chonetid with whorls.
 Normal Chonetid. The animal was an annellid worm which fed by extending outside their home and grabbed plankton.

Mollusks

 The most common pelecypods found are the Astartella subquandrata. Small but very detailed, they are the dominant clam.
 Permorphorus sp. are box shaped and we only found these three in the two gallons of rock.
 Rare and beautiful, Parallelodon anaklassium is a magnificent tiny clam with a wing like appendage along the hinge.
 Bakevellia sulcata. This unusual mollusk was pretty common in other sites finds, and seen here are two different modes of preservation.

Rugose Corals

 Lophamplexus sp. The crenelations on the exterior are diagnostic. Two specimens are shown here. The lowermost was quite crushed by the weight of the overlying sediment during diagenesis.
 End on view of the calice showing a chonetid made its home inside the vacant chamber after the coral had died. You can also see the partitions (septae) inside.
 A smaller coral of the same species. This is very uncommon - to find TWO rugose corals in such a small sample of rock. We only found one in past surveys after going through hundreds of pounds of limestone!

Crinoids

 Crinoid ossicles are are rare. These stem sections range in shape from round to star shaped and offer a glimpse into the diversity present in the Fort Apache Sea.

Gastropods

 Gastropods are the main faunal element in the Fort Apache fossils. Numerous species are seen here. An in depth identification of each type found from Winters monograph can be found here.
 The superb preservation of very small gastropods can be appreciated in this shot of a penny with four small gastropods in this image. They are so well preserved in many cases, the cavity inside is hollow as in life.

Cephalopods

 Orthocone nautiloids. Most likely cf. Psudorothoceras knoxense. Surprising that we found two speciemens in two different rocks from such a small sampling. The septa can be seen quite clearly in the lower specimen.

Ostracods

 Two genus of ostracods are found commonly in the Fort Apache. One type is a simple clam-shell type anatomy and the other are the hollowed out halves of a more complex ear shaped ostracod. Note the yellow straw colored silica that they are preserved with. This is the same as we find in the trilobites preserved. After all, they are all arthropods.

Scaphapods

 Hordes of scaphopods and thier juvinile teleoconchs were found. These are mostly Plgioglypta canna, and the banded smaller ones are thier teleoconchs.

Stellate Sponges

 Occasionally we find these magnificent tiny sponges that appear to radiate from a single attachment. The osculum is well preserved here, and as you can see from the scale, these are quite small indeed!

Straparollus Gastropods

 The juvinile straparollus gastropods seen here have not yet developed the ribbing and grooves along thier sides. As they grow to around half an inch in size, these features appear and then dominate. Preservation here is amazing. not only can the tiny protoconch (the embryo hatches in a small round shell in the middle) in the very center of the whorls be seen clearly, but the ends of the shell are open and hollow inside.

Trilobites

 Typical finds include all one species. These are the frontal rim around the crandidium and a few pieces of a free cheek. The color of the silica is diagnostic. All the trilobites preserve this color as do the ostracods.
 Free cheeks including the eye cut out. The trilobites are Phillipsia sp. and are not the same as found in the later Kaibab formation that overlies on the Rim.
 For the first time we have found thorax sections. This clearly identifies the trilobite as Phillipsia sp. They are not Ameura or Ditamopege found in the Kaibab.
 More frontal rims from the crandium.
 Heres a rare find - a set of ribs from the thorax floating in the fines! They are usually so delicate they break apart.

Echinoids

 Small pea sized to marble sizeed sea urchins lurked amongst the other faunal elements in the Fort Apache Sea. We find many dissarticulated urchin tests and spines in the mix, dominated by the spiny short spines for the larger sizes and smooth stubby ones for the smaller. Spine tubercles, water vascular apertures are common.
 These are the water vascular system openings that reside on the top of the Enchinoderm. They form a ring around the top and let water in to move the tube feet below.
 Smooth stubby spine types were commonly found at the zone 2 - East end location.
 Spine tubercle which is the mounting joint for the spines on the test of the Urchin.
 Rarely found, this is also located on the top of the urchin and disposed of waste material.

Sand, minerals, crystals

 There is a great deal of terriginous sediments in the Fort Apache Limestone. Most pieces we dissolved in the acid were 10 - 20 % dirt and clays. This for the most part is washed out since it is much finer than the fossils. Occasionally, larger sand grains can be found in the fines from the smalles sieve we use. We find quartz crystals, pink sand grains, yellow citrine, and a new find this time - Metallic grains.
 Remember that these are barely larger than a grain of sand. At the top is a layered chert, center a gorgous crystal of mica. Below it biotite mica probably from granite host rock on the shoreline many miles distant. On the bottom is one of the metal grains, most likely a manganese mineral. We find large pieces of manganese in the overlying Kaibab.
 Highest magnification with the stereo microscope on the mica crystal.
 Quartz sand. Clear, citrine yellow, and rose quartz.
 Metallic particles found amongst and within many of the fossils. The larger piece is actually wrapped around a sand grain. Reminds me of galena, molybdinite or manganese.
 Highest magnification for the metallic particles. You can see the metal crystals wrapping around a sand grain.

Larger sponges

 Larger macro fossils were also showing up in the acid fines. A larger quarter inch screen is used to get the big rocks and larger fossils out first, then we go finer after that with a good washing in between. These are calcareous sponges that have silicified. The scale in back is in 1 cm increments.

 

Productid Brachiopods\
 Productus sp. Same as in Kaibab formation. Out of the acid the spines are found in some cases still attached as seen here.

Larger Scaphapods

 Large Plagyoglypta sp. Scaphapod.

Paleo HOME